Is Google Docs Secure?

Google Docs has become a staple tool for creating, editing, and sharing documents online. With its intuitive interface and robust collaboration features, it has gained immense popularity among individuals and businesses alike. Whether it’s drafting a report, sharing meeting minutes, or collaborating on a project, Google Docs offers a seamless experience that caters to various needs.

Despite the convenience and efficiency that Google Docs provides, security remains a critical concern, especially for businesses handling sensitive information. Protecting confidential documents such as financial reports, strategic plans, and personal identifiable information (PII) is essential to prevent unauthorised access, data breaches, and potential financial and reputational damage.

BOOK A PLANETVERIFY DEMO TODAY →

1. Is Google Docs Secure?

Collaboration Benefits

Google Docs is renowned for its collaborative features, which include:

• Real-time Editing: Multiple users can simultaneously edit the same document, making it ideal for team projects and collaborative efforts.
• Cloud Storage: Documents are stored in the cloud, ensuring that they are accessible from any device with an internet connection, facilitating remote work and on-the-go access.
• Version Control: Google Docs automatically saves every change, allowing users to track document revisions and revert to previous versions if necessary.

These features make Google Docs an attractive tool for many users. Its ease of use and integration with other Google services enhance productivity and streamline workflows.

Security Concerns

Despite its strengths, Google Docs has several significant security weaknesses:

• Data Sensitivity: Google Docs is not designed to handle highly sensitive or confidential information such as proprietary business data, legal documents, and personal identifiable information (PII).
• Protection Limitations: The built-in security features of Google Docs, such as sharing restrictions and access expiration, are inadequate and can be easily bypassed.
• Inadequate Encryption: While Google encrypts data at rest and in transit, the level of encryption may not be sufficient to protect against sophisticated cyber attacks and unauthorized access.

These concerns highlight the potential risks associated with relying on Google Docs for secure document management, particularly for sensitive business information.

For more details on the limitations of password protection in Google Docs and why you need a better solution, refer to this PlanetVerify blog post.

2. Google Docs’ Security Mechanisms

Document Protection Features

Google Docs provides several features aimed at protecting documents from unauthorized access and modifications:

• Sharing Restrictions: Users can control who has access to a document by restricting permissions to view, comment, or edit. These settings can be customized for each collaborator, enabling a level of control over document interaction.
• Download, Print, and Copy Restrictions: To prevent unauthorized distribution, Google Docs allows users to disable options for downloading, printing, and copying content from the document.
• Access Expiration: Users can set an expiration date for access, ensuring that collaborators can only view or edit the document for a limited time period.

Limitations

While these features offer basic protection, they are not foolproof and can be circumvented:

• Bypassing Controls: Users with technical knowledge can bypass these restrictions using browser developer tools or third-party software. For example, disabling JavaScript or accessing the document in mobile view can allow users to copy or download content despite restrictions.
• Lack of Granular Control: The level of control over document permissions is not sufficiently granular for high-security environments. For instance, there is no way to prevent screen capturing or to apply different levels of restrictions to different sections of a document.
• No Control Over External Sharing: Once a document is shared, there is no way to control how it is further distributed. Even if permissions are set to view-only, recipients can take screenshots or share their access credentials with others, compromising the document’s security.

These limitations underscore the inadequacy of Google Docs’ built-in security mechanisms for protecting sensitive or confidential information.

3. Technical Vulnerabilities

Browser-Based Issues

The fundamental issue with Google Docs’ security is its reliance on the web browser:

• Client-Side Execution: Google Docs’ security features, such as copy/paste restrictions and print prevention, are implemented using JavaScript, which runs on the client side (i.e., the user’s browser). This makes these features vulnerable to tampering.
• Developer Tools Access: Most modern web browsers come with built-in developer tools that allow users to inspect and modify the code running on a webpage. By accessing these tools, users can disable JavaScript and bypass many of the security restrictions imposed by Google Docs.

JavaScript Weaknesses

JavaScript, while versatile and essential for web applications, has inherent security limitations:

• Tampering: Users with even basic technical knowledge can modify or disable JavaScript, effectively removing any client-side restrictions. This can be done by opening the browser’s developer console and running custom scripts or disabling scripts altogether.
• Inconsistent Behavior: JavaScript behavior can vary across different browsers and browser versions. This inconsistency can lead to security features being less effective or even non-functional in certain environments.

These vulnerabilities make it clear that relying solely on browser-based security mechanisms is insufficient for protecting sensitive documents. For high-security requirements, a more robust solution is necessary, one that does not rely on client-side execution and is not easily bypassed by browser tools.

4. User-Related Vulnerabilities

Password Sharing

Google Docs’ security is heavily dependent on user credentials:

• Shared Access: Users can share their Google account passwords, which grants full access to all documents associated with that account. Even with two-factor authentication (2FA), if the second factor is shared (e.g., via a phone), it doesn’t provide additional security.
• Weak Passwords: Many users employ weak or commonly used passwords, making it easier for malicious actors to gain unauthorized access through brute force attacks or password guessing. Google provides guidelines on creating strong passwords in their password security tips.

Intentional Leaks

Even non-technical users can inadvertently or deliberately bypass security measures:

• Screenshots: Users can take screenshots of sensitive documents, completely bypassing copy protection and download restrictions. Screenshots can then be shared easily via email, messaging apps, or social media.
• Social Engineering: Malicious actors can exploit human behavior through techniques like phishing or social engineering to trick users into revealing their login credentials or sharing sensitive documents.

These user-related vulnerabilities highlight the challenges of relying on user behavior for document security. Even with strict policies and training, there is always the risk of intentional or unintentional security breaches by users.

5. Ineffective Watermarks

Watermark Limitations

Google Docs offers a watermark feature to help protect documents, but it has significant drawbacks:

• Easy Removal: Users can remove watermarks by simply appending /mobilebasic to the document URL. This switch to the mobile view strips away watermarks and other visual restrictions.
• Static Watermarks: Google Docs does not support dynamic watermarks that automatically include user-specific information such as the user’s name or email address. Static watermarks do not effectively deter unauthorised sharing because they do not trace back to an individual user.

Workarounds

Removing watermarks in Google Docs is straightforward and can be done in several ways:

• Mobile View: By appending /mobilebasic to the URL, users can access a simplified mobile view of the document where watermarks and some security restrictions are not applied.
• Disabling JavaScript: Users can open the browser’s developer tools and disable JavaScript, which can remove watermarks and other client-side security features. This can be done by pressing Ctrl + Shift + I to open the developer console, then pressing Ctrl + Shift + P, typing ‘Disable JavaScript’, and refreshing the page.

These workarounds demonstrate how easy it is to bypass watermark protections in Google Docs. For businesses that need to ensure their documents remain secure and traceable, relying on Google Docs watermarks is insufficient.

6. Tracking and Monitoring

Tracking Features

Google Docs provides tracking capabilities, particularly for business and enterprise users:

• Activity Logs: Administrators can view logs that detail document activities such as views, edits, and shares. These logs include information like email addresses and IP addresses of users who accessed the documents.
• Email Notifications: Users can receive notifications when a document is accessed or edited, helping to keep track of any changes or unauthorized access.

Limitations of Tracking

Despite these tracking features, there are several limitations:

• Opt-Out Option: Users have the ability to opt-out of tracking, which can hinder the effectiveness of monitoring unauthorized access. Once users disable tracking, administrators lose visibility over document activities.
• Proxy Use: Users can mask their IP addresses using proxies or VPNs, making it difficult to identify the actual location or identity of users accessing the documents. This can lead to false positives or missed detections of unauthorized access.
• Limited Scope: The tracking does not extend to certain activities such as printing or copy-pasting. Even if tracking is enabled, users can still print the document or copy its contents to another file, which will not be reflected in the activity logs.

These limitations highlight the inadequacy of relying solely on Google Docs’ built-in tracking features to ensure document security. More robust and comprehensive solutions are needed to monitor and protect sensitive documents effectively.

7. Demonstration of Security Bypasses

How to Copy a Protected Google Doc

Bypassing the copy protection in Google Docs is relatively easy and can be done using a few simple steps:

1. Open the Document: Open the protected Google Doc in your browser.
2. Switch to Mobile View: Replace the /edit part of the URL with /mobilebasic. This switches the document to a mobile-friendly view that often strips away some of the protective features.
3. Open Developer Tools: Press Ctrl + Shift + I (or Cmd + Option + I on Mac) to open the browser’s developer tools.
4. Disable JavaScript: Press Ctrl + Shift + P, type ‘JavaScript’, and select ‘Disable JavaScript’. This will prevent the browser from executing any client-side scripts designed to enforce copy protection.
5. Refresh the Page: With the developer tools still open, press Ctrl + R or click the refresh icon to reload the page. After the page reloads, you should be able to copy and paste the document’s contents.

Converting Google Docs to Unprotected PDFs

Even if printing is disabled, users can save Google Docs as PDFs, bypassing restrictions:

• With Watermarks: If printing is enabled, users can press Ctrl + P and select a PDF printer (e.g., Microsoft Print to PDF). The watermarks will remain in the printed PDF.
• Without Watermarks: Follow the steps to switch to mobile view and disable JavaScript, then select a PDF printer to save the document. This will remove any watermarks applied to the original Google Doc.

Step-by-Step Process to Remove Protection

1. Access Mobile View: Add /mobilebasic to the document URL.
2. Disable JavaScript: Open developer tools and disable JavaScript.
3. Print to PDF: Use the print function to save the document as a PDF without restrictions.

These methods illustrate how easy it is to bypass Google Docs’ built-in security features. For organizations that need to protect sensitive information, relying on Google Docs alone is insufficient.

8. Google Drive Security

Shared Service Weaknesses

Google Drive shares many of the same security issues as Google Docs because they are integrated services. Documents uploaded to Google Drive, whether they are Google Docs, Microsoft Word files, or simple text files, are often viewed through the Google Docs viewer. This integration introduces several weaknesses:

• Common Vulnerabilities: The same methods used to bypass security in Google Docs (such as disabling JavaScript or switching to mobile view) can be applied to documents stored in Google Drive.
• Account-Based Access: Access to documents in Google Drive is controlled by Google account credentials. This means that if someone obtains a user’s login information, they can access all documents associated with that account.

Additional Measures

To secure documents uploaded to Google Drive, additional security measures should be implemented:

• Pre-Upload Encryption: Encrypt documents before uploading them to Google Drive. This ensures that only authorised users with the decryption key can access the content. Even if someone gains access to the file, they won’t be able to read it without the decryption key.
• Third-Party Security Solutions: Use third-party security solutions that offer more robust protection than Google’s native features. These solutions can provide advanced encryption, access controls, and activity monitoring to ensure document security.

Steps to Enhance Google Drive Security

1. Encrypt Documents: Use software to encrypt documents before uploading them to Google Drive.
2. Implement Access Controls: Apply strict access controls to limit who can view or edit the documents.
3. Monitor Activity: Use third-party tools to monitor document access and activity for any signs of unauthorised access.

By taking these steps, you can significantly enhance the security of documents stored in Google Drive, protecting sensitive information from unauthorised access and potential breaches.

9. Enhancing Security

Encryption Options

Using encryption is a fundamental step in securing documents:

• Password Protection: Tools like Microsoft Word and Adobe Acrobat allow users to encrypt documents with passwords before uploading them to Google Drive. This ensures that only users with the password can access the document. However, password protection has its drawbacks:
  • Password Sharing: Users can still share the password along with the document link, compromising security.
  • Password Management: Managing multiple passwords can be cumbersome and prone to errors, leading to potential security breaches if passwords are lost or improperly stored.

Drawbacks of Password Protection

• Intentional Sharing: Authorised users can intentionally share passwords, bypassing security.
• Single Point of Failure: Using the same password for multiple documents introduces a single point of failure. If the password is compromised, all documents are at risk.
• Inconvenience: Managing different passwords for each document is time-consuming and can lead to user frustration and errors.

DRM Solutions

Digital Rights Management (DRM) offers a more robust alternative to traditional password protection:

• Access Control: DRM solutions control access to documents without relying on passwords. Access is granted through a secure licensing system, which is more difficult to bypass.
• Usage Restrictions: DRM can enforce usage restrictions such as preventing copying, editing, printing, and screenshotting of documents. These restrictions are applied directly to the document and are enforced by the DRM system.
• Tracking and Revocation: DRM solutions provide the ability to track document usage and revoke access if necessary. This is particularly useful for ensuring that only authorised users have access to sensitive information.

PlanetVerify as a Solution

PlanetVerify provides advanced document security solutions that go beyond traditional password protection:

• Enhanced Security: PlanetVerify uses strong encryption and a robust licensing system to control document access.
• Convenience: PlanetVerify eliminates the need for managing multiple passwords by providing centralised access control.
• Comprehensive Protection: With PlanetVerify, documents are protected against unauthorised copying, editing, printing, and screenshotting.
• Detailed Tracking: PlanetVerify offers detailed tracking of document usage, helping organisations monitor access and detect potential security breaches.

By implementing DRM solutions like PlanetVerify, organisations can significantly improve the security of their documents, protecting sensitive information from unauthorised access and misuse.

10. Using PlanetVerify for Better Protection

Introduction to PlanetVerify

PlanetVerify specialises in secure, automated document collection and workflow automation. It is the perfect solution for businesses in various sectors such as legal, finance, HR, and real estate, ensuring compliance with data protection regulations like GDPR, KYC, and AML.

Features and Benefits

PlanetVerify offers several features that significantly enhance document security:

• Strong Encryption: Ensures that documents are only accessible to authorised users.
• Automated Workflows: Automates the document collection process, sending reminders to clients and reducing the manual effort required.
• Secure Viewer: Documents can only be accessed in a secure viewer, preventing unauthorised actions like copying, editing, printing, and screenshotting.
• Dynamic Watermarks: Adds user-specific information to documents, which helps trace any unauthorized distribution.
• Compliance and Security: Meets the highest security standards and ensures compliance with GDPR and other data protection regulations.

How to Use PlanetVerify

Using PlanetVerify to protect your documents is straightforward. Here’s a step-by-step guide:

1. Protect Documents:
   • Use PlanetVerify to encrypt and apply security controls to your documents.
   • Set up automated workflows to handle document collection and send reminders to clients.
2. Upload Securely:
   • Upload protected documents to Google Drive or distribute them through other secure methods.
   • Even if accessed, the documents cannot be opened without proper authorisation.
3. Assign and Monitor Access:
   • Use PlanetVerify’s centralised dashboard to assign access to authorised users and monitor the status of document submissions.
4. User Registration and Access:
   • Users receive an email with instructions to access the secure viewer, ensuring they can view but not alter documents.

Advantages of Using PlanetVerify

• Enhanced Security: Provides robust protection beyond traditional password methods.
• Efficiency: Automates document collection, saving time and reducing errors.
• Comprehensive Protection: Covers all aspects of document security, from encryption to compliance tracking.
• Ease of Use: Intuitive interface that integrates seamlessly with existing systems.

By integrating PlanetVerify into your document management process, you can ensure that sensitive information remains secure and compliant with industry regulations.

If you would like to learn more about PlanetVerify, please reach out today!